1.- The irrevocable power of attorney within the structure of security arrangements
Alternative property financing requires the establishment of mechanisms that enable the lender to protect its position without compromising the viability of the project in question. Alongside contractual obligations, representations and warranties by the borrower, the mortgage as the security par excellence, or the pledge of company shares, the irrevocable power of attorney emerges as an additional security for the lender.
However, the usefulness of this legal instrument must be understood on the basis of a fundamental premise: the irrevocable power of attorney must be regarded as a mandate serving an underlying contractual relationship from which it derives, rather than as an autonomous security interest; this is particularly significant given that such irrevocable powers of attorney confer powers of disposal over property.
2.-Basis and justification for irrevocability
From a predominantly civil law perspective, and in accordance with the provisions of our Civil Code, all powers of attorney are revocable insofar as their grant is an expression of a relationship of mutual trust between the principal and the agent. Consequently, in the event of a loss of such trust, provision must be made for the principal’s right to revoke what they had previously granted.
The matter at hand is a different one: that of powers of attorney granted within the framework of an alternative property financing transaction, where such powers arise as a consequence of an underlying contractual relationship, the existence of which is an essential requirement for these powers to be considered irrevocable.
Legal doctrine, and indeed the case law of our Supreme Court from a very early stage, are unanimous on this point. Both doctrine and case law readily accept the irrevocability of powers of attorney when, principally, two circumstances are present:
- that the power of attorney does not serve the interests of the principal exclusively—that is to say, in the context of such financing transactions, the borrower; and
- that such a power of attorney forms part of a legal relationship which also protects the interests of the agent, that is to say, the lender.
Indeed, in these alternative financing transactions, the concept of an irrevocable power of attorney is intended to serve as a further guarantee in favour of the agent (the lender), enabling them to dispose of the property in question in the event of non-payment of the debt by the borrower.
3.- Limits on the realisation of the property: forfeiture clause and Marcian clause
Consequently, and quite apart from the mortgage security established in this type of transaction, the irrevocable power of attorney provides the lender with practical protection, within the limits of the mandate conferred, which are usually those relating to the conditions under which the property must be disposed of in the event of non-payment by the borrower.
Consequently, and in order to avoid contravening the prohibition on forfeiture clauses enshrined in Articles 1859 and 1884 of the Civil Code—which prevent the creditor from taking possession of the assets pledged as security or from acquiring ownership of the property merely due to non-payment of the debt within the agreed period— the irrevocable power of attorney must contain clear and precise provisions regarding the terms under which such disposal is to take place.
In this regard, the legal doctrine issued by the Directorate-General for Legal Certainty and Public Trust (formerly the Directorate-General for Registries and Notaries) has recognised mechanisms for realisation or adjudication that incorporate an objective valuation procedure, which is understood to preclude abuse of the debtor.
This is where the concept of the Marcian agreement comes into play; in contrast to the forfeiture clause, it is designed to ensure that the creditor does not receive a sum in excess of what is legitimately due to them, nor take possession of the property solely on the grounds of non-payment of the debt. However, a mere generic reference to market value is not sufficient; rather, the procedure for determining the price at which the property is to be sold must offer sufficient and effective safeguards, whilst respecting the debtor’s legal position.
4.-Content of the power of attorney and conditions for its exercise
Thus, as a general rule, the irrevocable power of attorney must contain clauses stating that the creditor shall not acquire the property for themselves or for related persons or entities; the price, or the method of determining it under the conditions set out above, should the sale go ahead; when the debt in question shall be deemed unpaid, that is, within what timeframe the debt may be deemed to be liquid, due and payable; the commitment on the part of the authorised lender to enter into the potential sale and purchase on market terms, with an obligation to use their best endeavours to do so; and the return to the debtor, where applicable, of any surplus amount resulting from the sale and purchase that exceeds the sum owed to the creditor.
5.- Conclusion: an instrumental security at the service of financing
To summarise the above, the soundness of the irrevocable power of attorney, as an additional security in the context of alternative property financing transactions, depends on its consistency with the legal transaction it serves and on which it is based. This legal instrument derives its justification from a legally identifiable interest; its powers, from specific actions; and its continued existence, from the purpose that explains its irrevocability.
Consequently, the further the content of the irrevocable power of attorney strays from the function that is legally inherent to and permitted for it, and the closer it comes to a discretionary power to appropriate or realise the debtor’s assets, the greater the risk of it being challenged.
Ultimately, in transactions relating to alternative property financing, the irrevocable power of attorney must be granted as a supplementary measure that serves to reinforce the security structure established in this type of transaction. Its value lies not in transforming the creditor into the owner of the property, nor in granting them an entirely discretionary means of recovery, but rather in providing greater legal certainty to the contractual relationship established between the lender and the borrower – the agent and the principal, respectively – and in ensuring that the creditor can realise the property.

